A new shop in a Cambridgeshire village on a site that has been derelict for 13 years has met surprising opposition to it being used for a new Co-operative convenience store.
If Lincolnshire Co-operative thought their proposals for the small village of Coates – between March and Whittlesey – would find universal approval, they have been mistaken.
Of the 100 comments on the planning portal of Fenland District Council where the application can be viewed, the vast majority of the 60 or so residents’ views oppose the store.
Up until 2010 the site had been the location of the family-owned business Anker of Coates, a John Deere dealership, which relocated to the outskirts of Coates; the site has remained vacant.
Lincolnshire Co-op, which in recent years has opened a similar store in Whittlesey itself, wants to build a ‘top-up’ shopping store for local residents “rather than a destination type shopping centre” it says in its application.
“The size of the convenience store is sustainable within the local community and does not depend on a wider catchment area for its sustainability”.
Here’s the size proposed
The proposed store provides approximately 382m² of retail space at ground floor which includes 280m² sales area, 102m² Back of House.
The Co-op says their store “enhance the site and general environment of the area”.
But that is not how many villagers see it.
“This is a threat for the village post office shop,” says one resident.
“March road is already very busy road, and this will increase more traffics; the Co-op would be on a blind bend and very dangerous access”.
Another says: “The post office is the lifeline for me since I have a visual impairment.
Site of a proposed new Co-op for Eastrea near Whittlesey
“The village is poorly serviced by the bus service. The nearest post office is 4 miles away. I am concerned about the increase in traffic and the vehicles crossing into and out to the new Co-op.”
One other resident says: “We already have a very good village shop and post office and there is a new Aldi being built at Eastrea nearby.
“There are 2 Co-ops and 2 Nisas in Whittlesey already.
“The village shop does a great job at providing a service to the local community and passing trade on the A605.
“However, it is unlikely the area would be able to support two retail premises and if the independent village shop were forced to close the area would lose its post office as well.
Site of a proposed new Co-op for Eastrea near Whittlesey
“The post office serves not only the village but the surrounding area and villages.
“Many elderly residents rely on the shop and post office for banking needs as well as their groceries.”
One other person wrote in to say “I oppose having a Co-op op as the site is on a blind bend and very close to the zebra crossing which the primary school children use.
“Access would be very dangerous as this part of the village is busy.
Co-ops are ‘incredibly expensive’
“Co-op are incredibly expensive shops as seen with the two already in Whittlesey .
“Our village shop does a great job at supplying us with a post office and convenience foods should villagers run short, and the new Aldi will be used for bigger shops.
“The danger it could potentially cause with the traffic slowing on the bend to turn in whilst parents try to get their children into school in time is not worth opening an expensive shop that won’t be used.”
One other local resident and business owner said: “I wish to object to this planning application on the grounds that it’s in an unsuitable location, due to there already being too many junctions/access points onto the main A605 in too short a stretch of road, around this location.
“This part of the village is already too busy, and it includes the primary school, the only pedestrian crossing in the village and a known problem high speed bend.
Site of a proposed new Co-op for Eastrea near Whittlesey
“ In the 400 meters from Church Gardens to Feldale Lane there are currently 10 junctions/access Roads onto the A605. “Adding yet another busy traffic and pedestrian junction/access in this location is unsuitable.”
One resident said: “Coates has an existing village shop and post office, the proposed Co-op is of a size and scale out of character with our village community.”
7-10pm opening is a concern
He added: “The store proposes to be open 7a.m. – 10p.m, 7 days a week this will bring noise, litter and light pollution to neighbouring homes as well as possible anti-social behaviour in the car park – revving engines, loud music from cars both in and out of trading hours.
“The size of the building and close proximity to the homes behind it will result in considerable loss of light and overshadowing.
“The visual impact from all aspects of the building will be detrimental to the village and is entirely out of keeping with the surrounding environment.”
Another felt that “building a Co-op store on the main road in the small village of Coates is a very bad idea.
“The position of the shop will be dangerous as it is close to a blind bend and near the pedestrian crossing. My fear is that an accident will occur.
“I walk my child to and from school in Coates daily. At the moment, we run the gauntlet of all manner of vehicles whizzing through the village”. A
“Another concern is that the small family run shop in the village will close if a shiny new Co-op is built. If the shop closes, we will lose the post office & this would be a tragedy for the many residents who rely on it.
One other felt there had been “lack of consultation with local residents, communication very poor.
“This development does not add to the local community and will undermine local businesses”.
Another resident said “this shop is just not needed; we have a large Aldi within 2 miles of the plans and also a local shop.
We need a GP surgery first
“Try building another doctors’ surgery instead – something we actually need.”
A handful of comments were in agreement with the store being built.
“I would love this so much,” said one resident. “The little shop in Coates is ok but the owners are rude.”
And another felt that the “current site is an over grown eyesore with rusty shipping containers and has been for years.
“It could slow the traffic through the village as most residents are witness to traffic speeds through Coates of well over 50 mph, but no one seems to care about that.
“Many residents will oppose this; however, they DO NOT live opposite this site. It would be a welcome addition to have a landscaped area, with a CLEAN, tidy shop selling fresh produce”.
And a third felt it a “great use for this brown field site. The current village shop is too small for this expanding village. I strongly support this application”.
One hold up in making a decision is county highways who has hold Lincolnshire Co-op they need more information to “make an informed decision”.
No date for deciding the application has been given.
